Alternate Universe Fixation: Living in the “What If”

Why are we obsessed with what if? The psychology behind alternate universe fixation—where fanfiction AUs, multiverse theories, and daydreamed realities feel more real than actual life. #AUObsession #WhatIfThinking

📚 FICTIONAL & NARRATIVE

7/23/20254 min read

The Allure of the Unlived Life

You’re watching your favorite show, and you think:
What if they had made a different choice?
What if the villain had been the hero?
What if the story had gone another way?

You’re not just imagining. You’re living in the alternate universe—a parallel version of the story where everything is different, and somehow, more satisfying.

This is the fixation with “what ifs”—a powerful emotional and psychological pull toward alternate realities, fan-created timelines, and unlived possibilities. And it’s not just about fiction. It’s about how we process regret, longing, and the desire for control.

What Is Alternate Universe Fixation?

Alternate Universe (AU) fixation is the emotional and cognitive obsession with imagining or consuming versions of stories, characters, or even personal lives that diverge from the original timeline.

It often shows up as:

Reading or writing AU fanfiction
Reimagining character roles or endings
Obsessing over “what could have been”
Escaping into multiverse or time-travel narratives
Projecting personal regrets onto fictional rewrites

You’re not just escaping reality—you’re rewriting it.

Why We Crave the “What If”

🧠 1. Regret and Emotional Rewriting
Alternate universes let us undo pain. They let us imagine a version of life—or a story—where things went “right.” It’s emotional wish fulfillment.

🧠 2. Control in a Chaotic World
In real life, we can’t go back. But in fiction, we can. AU stories give us the illusion of control over time, fate, and consequence.

🧠 3. Identity Exploration
What if you had made a different choice? What if you had grown up somewhere else? AUs let us explore versions of ourselves we never got to be.

🧠 4. Emotional Depth and Novelty
Seeing familiar characters in unfamiliar settings (e.g., modern AUs, villain redemption arcs) creates emotional freshness and deeper connection.

Real-Life Story: The AU That Felt More Real

Noura, 26, was obsessed with a fantasy series where the main character dies tragically. She couldn’t accept it. So she started reading AU fanfiction where he lived, fell in love, and got a second chance.

“I knew it wasn’t canon. But it felt more real to me. It gave me closure the original story never did.”

Eventually, she realized she wasn’t just grieving the character—she was grieving her own past. The AU became a safe space to process that pain.

What Is the Real Story?

The real story is this: Alternate universes are emotional mirrors.

They reflect our regrets, our hopes, our unlived lives. They’re not just about fiction—they’re about healing. About imagining a world where we were loved better, chose differently, or got the ending we deserved.

But they can also become traps.

When we live too long in the “what if,” we risk losing touch with the “what is.” We romanticize the impossible. We delay acceptance. We avoid the discomfort of reality.

The Emotional Cost of AU Obsession

Difficulty accepting canon or real-life outcomes
Emotional detachment from present reality
Idealization of fictional or alternate selves
Avoidance of grief, regret, or closure
Over-identification with fantasy narratives

You may think you’re just being creative—but you might be using AUs to avoid emotional truths.

How to Rebalance Your Relationship with “What Ifs”

✅ 1. Notice the Pattern
Are you imagining alternate outcomes to escape pain—or to process it?

✅ 2. Let Yourself Grieve the Canon
It’s okay to feel disappointed or hurt by how a story ends. Let yourself feel it fully.

✅ 3. Use AUs as Tools, Not Escapes
Write or read AUs with awareness. Let them help you heal—but don’t let them replace reality.

✅ 4. Reflect on Your Own “What Ifs”
What alternate version of your life are you clinging to? What would it take to accept the one you’re in?

✅ 5. Create Closure in the Present
You can’t rewrite the past—but you can write your next chapter. In real life.

FAQs

❓ Why do I get obsessed with alternate universe stories?
Because they offer emotional safety, control, and the chance to rewrite painful outcomes—both fictional and personal.

❓ Is it unhealthy to live in “what if” scenarios?
Not inherently. But if it prevents you from accepting reality or moving forward, it may be worth exploring deeper emotional needs.

❓ How do I stop obsessing over alternate versions of my life?
Practice mindfulness. Reflect on what you’re avoiding. Seek closure through journaling, therapy, or creative expression.

❓ Are alternate universe fanfics bad?
Not at all! They can be healing, creative, and powerful. The key is to use them consciously—not as a permanent escape.

Final Thoughts: You Don’t Need a Different Universe to Heal

You don’t need to rewrite the past to find peace.
You don’t need a perfect ending to feel whole.
You don’t need an alternate universe to live a meaningful life.

Sometimes, the most powerful story is the one you’re living—right now.

💡 Remember:

Take a moment to reflect: How does this relate to your own obsessions?

Not everything you obsess over needs a cure ... Not every fascination needs fixing.

Some obsessions just need understood, Some just deserve to be seen.

🧭 This entry is just the beginning — Obsessionpedia is just getting started — and it's growing. Stay tuned for updates and new features coming soon. 🔍 Keep exploring — discover more topics that speak to you. New posts added daily , every obsession has a story , Reflect on your own.